Sometimes I hate when I’m right. It puts me in a bad position. Recently, being right hurt someone I care a lot about.
As predicted in last week’s post, I busted Jane for being on Facebook chat the minute her father and I left for work yesterday. Her father had grounded her less than a week ago from all things internet for a month. I caught her in her brother’s room two days later – she jumped from the side of his room with the computer on it to the side with the tv and DVD player as I was coming down the stairs. She tried to sit on the couch very nonchalantly but I’m not stupid. I know what she was up to, but I let it go.
But yesterday morning I checked her Facebook account and there it was: she had left a message box open in which she was begging one of her friends to talk to her. Time? 6:47 AM. (We had left for work at 6:30 AM).
I sent an email note to my hubby with the conversation copied. Just in case she tried to bullshit her way out of it, I even sent him a screenshot of the message left open.
Her actions don’t surprise me anymore. They really don’t. She doesn’t give a flying f*ck about anything her father says to her. Punishments mean nothing to her. As previously mentioned, she always finds a way to get around them.
But on Saturday I found something that I wish I hadn’t. I found a school assignment on her bed, unfinished. A speech she wrote on ‘who I admire the most’.
Guess who she admires the most?
That’s right, friends and neighbours: her mother.
Then I made a really bad decision. I showed the assignment to her father.
In the speech, Jane writes about what little she knows of her mom’s life, the schools she attended but never graduated from, the name of the restaurant where she now works as a waitress, the names of her four brothers and of her mom’s boyfriend.
But really - the reason she admires her mom the most? Because (and I am quoting here) “when I was sick in the hospital she came to see me as much as she could even though she had four other children at home”.
Um…. Excuse me? What fucking planet do you live on, kid?
The back story is this: when Jane was 7 or 8 (I wasn’t around so pardon me if the timing is off a bit) she developed an abscess on her leg. It was incredibly serious. Her father – who has a medical and nursing background - insisted that she be transferred from the local hospital in Bville to the children’s hospital here. As soon as she was admitted he was with her. FOR THE ENTIRE TWO WEEKS SHE WAS IN THE HOSPITAL. He never left. Even though he was self-employed at the time, and lost two full week’s pay, he did not leave her. He was with her during all her tests, needles and treatments. He fought with the nurses when he disagreed with what they were doing, and provided support to Jane when she was scared of the needles. He slept in her room on a cot. I think he went to his apartment twice in those two weeks.
Jane’s mom? Visited from Bville twice. Twice in two weeks. And for a while, the situation with Jane was critical – I think she was even in a coma at one point. Again, not having been there, I can’t be certain of all the details.
Oh, and there weren’t four other kids at home at the time this happened – there were only three. The youngest wasn’t even conceived yet.
But I digress….
Reading this assignment hurt my husband. A lot. More, I think, than he admitted to me. He was hurt that the person Jane admires most is her mother, whom he considers to be a very weak person.
But I understand why Jane chose her mother: Jane doesn’t really know anyone else. She would never say she admires her father or me the most because, let’s face it – we’re mean. She used to write in her journal how much she hated me. ‘I hate Heather’ was written all over her journal. Why? Because I usually do 90% of the child care in the house because of my husband’s work schedule so the punishing and grounding (and policing) fell to me. She would NEVER write that she hated her father, so I was the scapegoat.
She doesn’t get along well enough with her grandmother (they both have bitchy attitudes and are exactly alike so they spark off each other). Jane has one aunt that is stay-at-home with three kids of her own. She doesn’t know her aunt very well.
So then – who else would she write about? Since she’s lived with us, her mother has been the shining star. No matter what terrible things she has done lately (moving 12 hours away, not returning phone calls, no contact for weeks, etc.) it doesn’t matter. Jane is smitten with her mother.
It makes sense when you think about it. Her mother doesn’t punish her. Her mother doesn’t make her write apology notes to her French teacher. Her mother doesn’t take away her hair straightener or the internet or her phone privileges. Her mother doesn’t tell her that she’s too young to have a boyfriend. In fact, I hear Jane telling her mother all about her boyfriend troubles when she’s on the phone with her. So it’s only natural that Dad is now the ‘bad guy’.
And he told me last night, after his talk with Jane about the Facebook thing, that he’s done dealing with her. He told her to make a choice – live here by his rules or she can go live with her mother.
He didn’t say it meanly, of course. Those of you who know my husband may be shocked to realize that he is a rational man when it comes to serious discussions. He doesn’t yell. He doesn’t raise his voice. He speaks calmly and clearly. And, as a woman, it’s really annoying to fight with someone who speaks so rationally and calmly all the time.
As I only heard the conversation from his point of view – and parts of it - I can’t report everything that was said. I do know that tears were shed. But there was no anger in his voice.
Only disappointment.
He got Jane’s standard ‘I don’t know” answer to why she was doing stuff once again that she had been told not to do. It’s really nothing new.
So he told her – calmly, nicely – that perhaps she would be happier living with her mother and her brothers. Perhaps since she admires her mom so much she should be with her. He told her to take her time and make a decision if she wants to go live with her – even so far as to ask her to call her mom and talk to her about it.
Of course more tears ensued. But fellow readers - you know, and I know – she won’t say to her father that she wants to go live with her mother. Even if she really, really wants to.
Because she’s scared.
She’s scared that her father will never let her come back to visit if she decides to go live with her mother, which is ridiculous. She’s scared because she will have to transfer schools and will have to make new friends in a new city. Which she had to do when she moved with us two and a half years ago.
She’s scared, because she will feel rejected by her father. Which I don’t understand at all, because she seems to be rejecting him every chance she gets.
Between you and me, I want her to go live with her mother. Send her there at Christmas and have her switch schools then. It’s not because I dislike her – although she does everything in her power to try to make that happen. It’s because I really do think she would be happier there. Happier to be with her mom. Happier to be with her younger brothers. Happier to not have two dogs. Happier to be once again the only girl in a house full of boys. Happier to share confidences with her mom that she won’t share with her father – or with me, for that matter.
Sure, she’ll miss her friends. She might even miss her brother. Maybe even her dad, once things settle down.
But she’ll make new friends. She did it when she moved with us two and a half years ago, so she can do it again.
But she won’t make that decision. She’ll say she wants to live here, her dad will talk again to her about her attitude and stuff but nothing will change. The cycle will start all over again.
I think my husband needs to just send her to live with her mom – to take the choice away from Jane. It seems as though she is doing everything she can to push herself away from him. I think – and you know how I am a great armchair shrink – that she wants to go live with her mom badly but is afraid of the ramifications of making that decision. So she constantly acts out with bad behaviour so that her father will make her go live with her mom, making HIM the bad guy. Jane will get the ‘poor me’ story of how her father sent her to live with her mother because he doesn’t love her and oh isn’t that terrible.
A few of my friends have told me they can’t believe how much of a bitch Jane is all the time. Really though, she’s not.
She’s just a scared little girl, who doesn’t know who she is. There’s not a doubt in my mind that if we went back in time two and a half years, and gave the kids the choice of where to live, Jane would have chosen to stay with her mom instead of coming to live with us.
She’s just too scared right now to say those words to her father. So I say make the choice for her. Make plans and arrangements for her to go live with her mom. Not as a punishment, but because it really is the best thing for everything right now.
But you know and I know that will never happen. My husband won’t send her to live with her mother, and Jane isn’t going to suddenly change her sneaky ways.
So the big question I send out to cyberspace is….
Now what?
Happy Ghost and Goblin day
1 week ago








